I am in the exact same boat as you, with regards to getting a new daily in a similar budget. Will be looking to purchase sometime in Q1 next year, interested to see what choice you make - only caveat for me, it needs to be an SUV/SAV, as my SO will use the car as well.
I have 3 main choices (<3 years old and balance of plan):
VW Tiguan
Mazda CX5
Nissan Qashqai
My only issue is, I can't step away from the BMW stable, even though that means a slightly older model. I really like the F25, X3 Motorsport (I know that this kit sort of negates any off-roading, which suits me fine). Chances are I will end up in a BMW with the tail end of plan and will then maintain myself.. Would like a 3.0d but for my purposes, a 2.0d would do fine as well.