X3 trade value

TOOFAST MP

New member
Hi Guys does anyone know what trade and retail shouid be on a 2007 E83 L.C.I. X3 20d Xdrive Motorsport in mint condition, with full history 113k'KM
I phoned a dealer and I'm shure they trying to shaft me ,
When I look on the net at prices they are going for I'm shure they smoking there sox ..

Cheers
 
M

Mike1

Guest
Okay a question for those complaining about how the dealer wants to shaft them, talk to me about your Motorplan... Has it been extended? Are you trading in because its due an extension?

Has your Motorplan already been extended once before or is the car out of plan OP?
 

TOOFAST MP

New member
I phoned the dealer where I got my car, Out of intreast I have done 11k.KM since I got it I paid R282K including a good breakdown plan that was R16'K including the wear and tear waiver fee ..........was offerd R145K. On. Trade in and it mint condition new tyres.
:cry:wtf
 

TOOFAST MP

New member
No it had just finished when I got it ..........there's a few on the net no motorplans with between 140-169k km. At R230k to R245K
 
M

Mike1

Guest
Theres your problem, you paid too much. The second any vehicle goes off plan it loses anything from R40k - R100k of its value instantly and you paid for a car with the perceived peace of mind of a Motorplan because of the FSH and mileage but in the trade it has no Motorplan, bye bye R50k like that.

Aftermarket Plan means nothing on a BMW - its worth nothing in terms of trade value.

The reason your trade value is so low is simple.

1. Its an X3 with over 100k on the clock, the perceived nature of that vehicle and most BMW's is that it is about to explode.
2. Its an X3 with no Motorplan, any repair costs will need to be absorbed by the dealer, why would they give you money to lose money?
3. Its an X3. Thats the biggest problem. You have an awesome vehicle but the problem is that because of the above no dealer trading it in, even with perfect tyres will want it on their floor.

Its a ticking time bomb to a potential dealer. The turbo could go, a simple squeak detected by a new customer can cost them R12k in bushes alone and the X3 is simply not as desireable as at the same price you can get a 3.0D or 4.4 Litre X5 with similar mileage - Lets play devils advocate and chuck in the new CPA and you will see clearly why the dealer would sooner trade in a vanilla golf 5 than your X3.

The case in point here is that any dealer you trade the car in with is not going to make money off your car, they are going to sell it to the trade which means you are never going to get anything more than the trade value in the book as the trade itself wants to pay a lot less for your car.

I may be coming across as an utter tosser, its not the intention at all but you purchased a car at the worst time in its life and thats not your fault, its just the BMW way and the fact is whoever you bought the car from screwed you nicely, the same applies to the other people on this forum complaining about trade values.

If I explain to you how the trade see's extras on a car you will cry yourself to sleep tonight. :argh:

Mike
 

TOOFAST MP

New member
:nonono:Best is though when you do sell for 145k the week after they will be selling it for 214K again
ALso the cpa and ombutsman are not worth jack shit , they like a toothless dog one of my workmates baught a ssangyong brand new its a lemon its totally fucked gives him 14l/100Km. The dealer can't fix it ,they have thrown away one of his spare keys given him a new uncut key that is not programed as they claim there is only one diagnostic computer in the country .they told him to go to do as he pleases and he. Lodged a complaint with the ombutsman got a refrece number and the dealer was given 14 days to solve the issuses after 14.days No action and he contacted them again. He was told its upto the dealerto sort it out . This is on a
brand new car
 

MikeR

Well-known member
:thumbs: @MINIMIKE :thumbs: thats what is happening,
:fencelook: guys dont read what cars are being advertised on the net for (ie AUTOTRADER) they are not selling at those prices.
 

TOOFAST MP

New member
MikeR said:
:thumbs: @MINIMIKE :thumbs: thats what is happening,
:fencelook: guys dont read what cars are being advertised on the net for (ie AUTOTRADER) they are not selling at those prices.

Then why is it that cars are advertised for example. A 740i. For R 179.999 but if you want a deal it can be loaded upto R314 000 and approved by the bank. Banks don't just uprove any deal they won't finance a car if it is being sold for above book values .
Where is all the devaluation motorplan story then ?
 

prospect

New member
There's no way I'll pay the advertised price. I always pay just above trade since the dealer doesn't have much to worry about if the car has MP. Extras mean bugger all when you trade your car in. Don't get ripped off people!
 

pimpassdaddy

Well-known member
Like Mike said, the biggest problem with that car, it's an X3. Those cars have HORRENDOUS trade value. You'll easily get R40 - R50k behind book, before they've even seen it to properly evaluate it.

Sorry mate... Also, the reason why the dealers have such a high margin, is because that car will probably sit on the floor for months before getting sold, IF he tries selling it... Hence selling to the trade is better.

Rather keep it, or you'll have to pay in on it.

Sorry mate :nonono:
 
M

Mike1

Guest
X3 ///M said:
MikeR said:
:thumbs: @MINIMIKE :thumbs: thats what is happening,
:fencelook: guys dont read what cars are being advertised on the net for (ie AUTOTRADER) they are not selling at those prices.

Then why is it that cars are advertised for example. A 740i. For R 179.999 but if you want a deal it can be loaded upto R314 000 and approved by the bank. Banks don't just uprove any deal they won't finance a car if it is being sold for above book values .
Where is all the devaluation motorplan story then ?

Car Finance + Personal Loan. No bank, I repeat, no bank would approve a deal on any car like that. so dont know where you heard that. Pre the new credit laws etc yes, you could load any deal and they would approve it as banks were giving loans to everyone and everything, but we have the recent recession to thank for that.

I give you an example, we had two Hampton Cooper S Clubmans, limited edition models and hugely expensive, since I specced them full house, literally every option ticked.

These cars were priced at R480k each. Retail on a standard Clubman S is R290 000. Because of the Hampton Limited Edition Package (Something the banks have no clue of) the prices of these Clubmans rocketed.

We had two clients apply for finance with the banks, all of their applications were declined. The only bank, if it can be called that which would finance those cars was MINI Finance, why? Because they know its a limited edition.

Same applies with the trade value of a John Cooper Works MINI... It doesnt have one, so you pay a R150k premium to get the limited performance model and at trade time I kid you not they base your cars value off that of a Cooper S + R25k. Money gone!

You can load a deal... For example take a R300k BMW 3 series. The car has R40k trade assistance and R30k trade in assistance and a R20k margin. So you have R90k to make a deal happen and these figures are real by the way...

The client cannot get approved on a R300k car. So BMW then takes the R40k trade assistance and uses it as a deposit. Instantly the banks reconsider and they approve the loan. Then the client says payments are too high... So they add R30k to the customers trade in either settling it or improving their deposit and thus affordability further. And then, if they really need to the sales-person who gets a fixed comm per car he sells may chuck in R15k of his margin to ensure you sign that OTP.

So yes... You can make a R300k a R390k car on paper just by fooling with the assistance BMW offers. But to the banks you can also make a R300k car and a client who cant afford it look like a R210k car. Thats the definition of loading a deal.

No bank will approve a loaded deal where the total Invoice amount is higher than their recommended retail price for that vehicle and its extra's.

Devaluation on a BMW Motorplan is simple. It works like this... In order for BMW to sell you an Approved used vehicle it has to pass a quality check which the dealer pays R2k for from the cars margin. Any issues in the quality check must be rectified before delivery of the vehicle.

Furthermore, to qualify as an approved used vehicle the car must have a minimum of a year or 25 000km outstanding before Motorplan expires, if the vehicle does not qualify it must be sold as pre-owned and without the Approved status or the dealer must pay for the Motorplan extension.

To extend plan by time is cheap, its extending by mileage that is a problem. You want to trade in a 1 series... Its got 95 000km on the clock and 2 years plan left. To keep that car on their floor bmw will have to pay R25k to extend the plan... But the trade/retail difference leaves you with only a R20k margin if you give the client what the car is worth on paper... So thats when you start getting R5k below trade, then lets say it needs tyres, this must be accounted for... In order to be sold as approved used it needs to go for an approved valet, thats R750, the mag wheels need to have NO scratches or buckles so thats R2280 for full refurbishment, the vehicle may have no scratches itself, or paint defects and in order to extend motorplan it needs to be repaired by a BMW approved panelshop... They charge R4500k for a bumper!

So your 1 series has a trade of R200 000 and Retail of R230 000 now remove the above costs and you end up with a trade in value of well below R170k straight away... But, BMW dont want a 95 000km car on their floor, nobody will buy it! So they cut their losses and they offer your one series to the trade... The trade will offer R150k max and bham just like that you lose money just by trading ina car with motorplan too late.

Motorplan is a savior but if you do not understand the implications it has to extend etc then you will lose money! I dealt with far too many clients bringing in 320i E90's with 95 000km on the clock with under a year of plan left who couldnt understand why they were offered 30k under trade (just to extend that plan) or even less than that because the dealer doesnt want the car.

Hope it makes sense?

Mike
 
Top