X1 question- 20d Vs 23d?

[200 octane]

Hi fellow enthusiasts. We are considering upgrading the family wagon(07 Rav4 2.2 d4d) and are looking at the following options.
2011 fortuner facelift
2010 BMW X5 30d
2012 BMW X3
BMW X1 20d
BMW X1 23d

My reason for this post though is, what's the difference between the X1 20d and 23d? Which is most reliable?

 

[r0ckf1re]

Hi fellow enthusiasts. We are considering upgrading the family wagon(07 Rav4 2.2 d4d) and are looking at the following options.
2011 fortuner facelift
2010 BMW X5 30d
2012 BMW X3
BMW X1 20d
BMW X1 23d

My reason for this post though is, what's the difference between the X1 20d and 23d? Which is most reliable?

2.0 D


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Alex@Madnessmotorsport]

The 2.0d is a single turbo and the 23d is the twin turbo option.

 

[rad006]

Single Turbo will be the cheapest to repair in the log run should something break.

 

[Bayn46]

Hi fellow enthusiasts. We are considering upgrading the family wagon(07 Rav4 2.2 d4d) and are looking at the following options.
2011 fortuner facelift
2010 BMW X5 30d
2012 BMW X3
BMW X1 20d
BMW X1 23d

My reason for this post though is, what's the difference between the X1 20d and 23d? Which is most reliable?

The standard 20d and 30d engines are solid and very reliable (probably the 20d more than the 30d).

I went through a similar exercise when I was looking for something a bit bigger. Fortuner is super thirsty and a bit basic for the money, and the old X1 is dated especially if you don't get the 8-speed auto.

X3 is probably the better buy as the engine is extremely reliable, it'll be an xDrive model, and you'll get the 8-speed auto.

 

[200 octane]

Any views on the car attached
2011, 20d, auto, 187000km at R
180k

 

[Twinz]

X3 20.d Xdrive all the way...:thumbs:

In terms of the Facebook post you will have to view/test drive it to make a determination.

 

[200 octane]

I do like the one on the Facebook post. My concern is just related to whether or not that mileage is ok.

Furthermore, here's an X1 from webuycars

 

[Twinz]

That X3 milage is normal for a 2011 model...slightly over 22 000ks per annum which is not bad.

The X1 in your pic looks fresh and amazing. Whats the Ks on it?

 

[200 octane]

X1 mileage is 155k

 

[///M Individual]

Hi bud, I think size wise going from the Rav4 you will have to go for the X3 and the 2.0d motor is brilliant!

 

[200 octane]

Thread updated and replaced with the following;

https://www.bmwfanatics.co.za/showthread.php?tid=91136