This is the true fanatics way...

Coisman

Administrator
Staff member
:pimp:
Sank, would you be willing to help me to get Frikkieh's diff/driveshaft problem sorted?
He was there by my house last night, but he is so negative about the issue, he wants to put the car on blocks, and not drive it.
I am not the most technical guy, but I am willing, and eager and not scared to get dirty, so I will be more that able to assist.
So what you reacon?? :)
 

Sankekur

///Member
As always I would be more than willing to help, though I am not to sure whether I would be able to help/aid diagnosing the problem as I have a very limited experience with diffs.
 

Coisman

Administrator
Staff member
:pimp:
Well, I will speak to Frikkie, or maybe he would read this and make a post/new thread. Thanks :)
 

frikkieh

///Member
Gents, Thanks for offering. Got a call from Coisman about this. I would be greatful to have an extra hand around. I need an opinion about that whine - would it be my imagination or not. (or am I just looking for a new car :grin: )
Seriously thanks for offering, I will definately make use of the opportunity to have help around.
Here is the thread about the diff:

http://www.bmwfanatics.co.za/showthread.php?tid=19554

 
J

Jakkals_F30

Guest
Maybe i should find something wrong with my car to go visit LZ and have a look at the progress on the bird... :)
 

zaleonardz

Well-known member
Well, I learnt quite a bit when I did my manual swap, but I am a bit of a noob as well most of the times.

I have just re-read frikkie's original thread, and it sounds like most of the stuff I would of done has been done.

I am going to post an idea in his original thread though.
 

Sankekur

///Member
Right so just quickly back to the work that this thread is about. So it seemed that the work was done, but it would appear that this was only the end of the first act and we have now started with act 2 of this epic saga.

So today I was on my way back home from giving someone a hand with his BMW and a couple of km's from home, just after pulling away from a stop street, I start hearing a swishing noise from the engine bay, and because I did the belts just a couple of days before I immediately start thinking than on of the belt might have come off. So as quickly as I can a pulled to the side of the road and turned off the engine and opened the bonnet to investigate. And this is what I found: (The pics where taken after I had gotten home and opened things up a bit to take photos)
The belt that drives the aircon had was starting to fall to pieces, this just a couple of days after getting and fitting it:
DSCN2031.jpg


DSCN2030.jpg


DSCN2026.jpg


DSCN2025.jpg


So I decided that as this belt was is not crucial to the functioning of the car and because I was so close to home to just get the car home. And after driving a bit I got that tell-tale smell of coolant for a bit then it went away then I got it again. This started to worry me. So a minute or so later I get home and look at the front of the car and see spots of liquid underneath my bumper I smell a bit of it and I instantly know that it is coolant. Then I looked behind the car are there was a large stripe of coolant in the road and the drive were I had just driven. So I got the car parked as quickly as possible.

So with the car parked I investigated the problem further, and I found this:
DSCN2027.jpg


DSCN2033.jpg


One of the long stands that came loose of the belt had cut a hole in the rubber hose right next to it. And there my car was standing, loosing all the new coolant that I had put in just a couple of days earlier. Some pics of this sad sight:
DSC00796.jpg


DSC00799.jpg


I looked at the belt from every angle and it seems like it was perfectly fitted, not that there is really any other way of fitting it, due to the grooves you can be sure it is aligned. Also the belt stayed on so that would also seem to be that is was on properly. I felt around the area that the belt has to move in for anything that might have damaged the belt, but there is nothing. Then again I did all this checks when I fitted the belt. So I am certain the problem was with the belt itself.

The thing that catches me about this is that the belt had not even driven a real load since I had put it on since there is not really a reason to use the aircon, yet it still fell to pieces, this kind make you wonder about how good BMW's quality control is really.

At least I seem to have found a possible cause for why the belt failed so quickly (thanks to some inputs and things my mom noticed when she looked at the belt). It seems like the belt is constructed by two layers of rubber and sandwiched between this rubber is a rope-like clothy material. On the side of the belt that is not damaged you can see that the "rope" material is partially exposed, but not only that you can feel a small bit, like the tip of this "rope" sticking out, so if this tip gets torn out a little it could be enough for bits of the rubber starting to loosen and tear of like what happened on the other side of the belt. This is of course just speculation.

Either way I will be taking the belt back to the dealer to get a replacement or my money back, and hopefully I can get the damaged pipe out of them as well. But knowing BMW they will probably fight this tooth and nail, but we'll see.

I have to say I am not a happy camper :(.
 

zaleonardz

Well-known member
Not a happy camper, dude I would be down right swearing... Sorry for your troubles... :yuck:

Although, one has to ask, is it not possible that you have a drive belt system alignment issue, perhaps she is running true to the eye, but maybe one of the pulleys is moving in and out on its shaft or something.

It just seems really weird, I would suspect bearings in the water pump, but you replaced that.

Perhaps its just a bad quality belt...this sure is sucky.
I
 

Sankekur

///Member
The pulley that I got broken that I replaced and the waterpump all sit on the main belt (Waterpump, alternator, powersteering pump). This problem is on the other belt, the one that does the aircon. So all I did was to remove the old belt and put on the new one.

I replaced both belts while I was at it.

Either way I was at BMW this morning and it seems that there is two different belts used on the 330i a wider one and a narrower one, it seems my car take the narrower one and they supplied me with the wider one. So now apparently they will call me when they have spoken to the big cheese, the top dog (emphasis on the work dog) at this particular dealer, apparently this will happen on monday. So I guess I will wait and see.
 

Sankekur

///Member
Thanks, i have so say I am feeling a bit depressed about this whole matter, luckily a quick morning drive in the 540i sorted that out :)

But we will see what happens, I am thinking of just trying goldwagen and bemows to see if I can get hold of the pipe and belt, then with my car mobile again i won't mind if things with BMW drag out, as I have a feeling I will have to do a lot of waiting before this is sorted, that or BMW will just tell me to f***-off.
 

msm

Well-known member
I know the depressing feeling you get when your car is sick :argh: :cry:

Hope you sort out it soon.
 
Top