momo1 said:
I always thought of the X1 as Ugly, But gotta admit with the M-Sport kit and in white it does look the part.
Whats the drive like compare to the E60?
I never took a second look at them, until I sat in one, definitely a baby X but has its perks. In some respects, it is clear that BMW wanted to cut corners on this model, from the optional climate control, the clunky doors, even the way the outer door handles sound is just different to the E60.
It would be difficult to compare the two, considering they are on different ends of the spectrum. Some of the differences between the two to note:
X1 is on runflats vs E60 non-runflats
X1 is on 45/40 profile vs E60 on 35 profile
X1 is 8spd vs E60 which is 6spd
Driving the X1 in traffic is an absolute pleasure, mainly due to the 8spd box, higher seating position and low down torque. I find the comfort is better, but theres that annoying uncomfortable feeling when going over rough roads where the tyres seem to not want to absorb the bumps and the suspension is saying this road is too bouncy for me to absorb it all. It seems to me like it is a combination of the run-flats, the stiffer msport suspension as well as tyre pressure. I am curious to see if it disappears with normal tyres, but for now i am playing with pressures whenever i do drive it and can compare.
Theres a difference i the steering feel, where the E60 feels more direct, compared to the X1 which sometimes feels a little more out of touch, but not enough to complain. If i was driving the X1 all the time, I would not complain, the comparison is only felt because i might drive both cars in one day.
Theres definitely a difference in terms of the turbos, where the E60 is the older version and X1 is the twin power version. The torque at lower revs would give similar powered vehicles( non BMW) a good run.
When comparing the gearboxes, by the time the older 6spd decides ..., ok i am going to lock the torque convertor at this throttle and put the power down, the 8spd has already been accelerating for half a second longer, so the 8spd feels faster at low revs.
While the E60 might have more boot space, the X1 has more flexibilty in terms of folding seats and that comes in handy more often the bigger boot space.
Lastly, I have to say the standard sound on the X1 kills the standard sound, so BMW improved that over the years. THe E60 had just the 4in on doors, as well as rear parcel shelf and the underseat mids, while the X1 has the 4in splits in the front, 4in mids on the rear shelf, underseat midwoofers