NRF Radiators for E46 , anyone used them?

zippy320

Well-known member
I know the original BMW expansion tanks last much longer then the pirate ones . Also believe that the reason these tanks fail is because of that thermostat in the bottle that jams up causing very high pressure in the tank , causing it to crack . So cant put full blame on the tank .

Goldwagen has the NRF radiators for R1380


Loom said:
So NRF is to blame for the failing expansion tanks?
 

Tinuva

Staff & Webmaster
Staff member
zippy320 said:
I know the original BMW expansion tanks last much longer then the pirate ones . Also believe that the reason these tanks fail is because of that thermostat in the bottle that jams up causing very high pressure in the tank , causing it to crack . So cant put full blame on the tank .

Goldwagen has the NRF radiators for R1380


Loom said:
So NRF is to blame for the failing expansion tanks?

Isn't the thermostat separate from the expansion tank? The ET cracks if you overfill the system with coolant, that I know.
 

KPM3_30

Moderator
Staff member
Silverton had Behr radiators when I replaced mine. Was told they are OE on some e46's, could see the BMW part number area.
 

zippy320

Well-known member
On automatic cars there is a thermostat there , its a black plastic part , It controls the temp of the gearbox . I have attached a picture of this part , it fits inside the expansion tank at the bottom where the bottles attaches to the radiator support ( I think that's what its called)
Manual cars don't have these thermostats .




Charlie Brown said:
There is no t/stat in the expansion tank.

They crack because they are plastic and every heat cycle reduces the lifespan.

17111437362_4514879137.jpg
 

zippy320

Well-known member
Hi Charlie Brown
No worries , i should be the one to apologies , I didn't mention if the car was Auto or Manual , so sorry .

Yup from what I gather , through the net , speaking to mechanics at BMW etc , The expansion tank does crack due to age as its plastic , but on an auto, when the thermostat seizes , it causes a higher then normal pressure inside the tank , which can also lead to cracking . When I replaced my tank , and the tank of my aunts 325ti , in both cases , the thermostat had seized , in my case the plastic itself was extremely brittle , Just touching it broke the piece . I don't understand this use of plastic everywhere on our cars , its a joke . High pressure , expansion contraction and heat . These parts are just not built to last that long anymore.

As mentioned , I replaced my radiator with an NRF radiator , I found this website that has some good info on who makes what parts for our cars . I think it may be specific to the M3 but it seems like good advice .

http://www.m3forum.net/m3forum/showthread.php?t=566749

It states Modine / NRF as the manufacture , and from what I found , Modine owns NRF so this radiator was identical to my old radiator . Though once I had removed the radiator , I found that the original brand of my radiator was made by SMITHS from Pinetown in Sa , The plant is less then 5 minute drive from were I live ( If I had known I would have gone there haha) , which was stamped and marked all over with the BMW logos , part numbers etc. So it looks like BMW fitted these to our SA cars from factory . Makes me wonder if Smiths made our original expansion tanks as well .

http://www.smithsplastics.co.za/





Charlie Brown said:
Apologies Zippy

I have idea how or what autos do or work.

The rate that there all fail manual and autos is rather irritating,
 
Top