-
Read the WELCOME ALL BMWFANATICS post.
M135i replacement
- Thread starter stephen
- Start date
CocoPops
Honorary ///Member
stephen said:When I traded the M135i in for a more family oriented car (2016 X-Trail 2.5 AWD) I told myself I wasnt going to get another car for a few years until the kids are all gown up.
Almost two months later and i find myself test driving everything and anything. So ive decided (against my significant others pleading) to get something again.
My price range is up to 1 mill, financed with a deposit unfortunately not cash
A Nissan GTR would be first prize but parts are a little steep and most have none / if any motorplan or warranty left in that price bracket.
So ive short listed to either an M3/M4/M5 or a C63. They can all be picked up relatively new for around a mill. After test driving each I cannot decide what to go for.
My question is, is there any other cars that anyone can suggest i should look at, or any reason i should go for one over the other.
Hey,
What about a Cayman 981 GTS - they are absolutely fantastic cars, super focused, and has that glorious motor. Check the reviews, dont recall one that didnt give it 5/5 stars.
Also have a look at the 718 Cayman S - also a great car and can be had for below R1mn. The engine doesn't sound great, but is an absolute cracker of a car.
Also - since Porsche essentially controls the used car market, you will lose very little money in the short and long term.
That would be my pick below R1mn if practicality is not an issue, they deliver the best driving experience without a doubt to any other car in that price range, funny to get a better experience requires buying a Porsche GT car.
[video=youtube]
[video=youtube]
Sweet
Wes
///Member
5-10 years ago I would have agreed.individj said:
The Cayman has established it's rep as a competent, well sorted car in recent years.
To the OP, it all depends what you want out of the car?
Weekend drama? AMG all day and twice on Sunday.
Something to take on spirited drives? Probably an ///M of some kind.
Does it need space for the pram? A back seat? Would it need to serve as a backup car should the Nissan go for service? Would you want to drive it for 3 days in this weather if you had to?
All things to consider
individj
Well-known member
Wes said:
as i said..i would love to drive it & wouldnt be able to exploit it to its full abilities either if I'm honest..i don't think i would buy 1 though if it were my choice but as you stated there are many factors to consider...i like the fact that the R8 shares an engine with the RS4 bar the sump etc.
Either way the OP is in a great position to have all the choice currently available...i will say that car prices are crazy...the new C43 Coupe is a beautiful car too
FerdiBotha
Well-known member
Jeremy.d said:
There is no way a 330d will be even remotely close to an M3/M4.
With the performance pack it pushes out 210kw and 600nm vs the M3/M4 with 317kw and 550nm. These figures don't even tell half the story of what will actually happen out on the road - the 330d will have front row seats to seeing a very big hiding being dished out in a drag race.
Thanks for suggestions and advice guys. Some really interesting points raised. Some cars I had never even considered thinking that theyre way out my budget. A porsche for 1 mill is ridiculous. Although I'm not sure If a pure drivers car like a Porsche would be a waste given my driving talent or lack thereof
cOlDFuSiOn
New member
How about a F Type Jag? Or maybe a 911? I find myself spotting them more and more, they really stand out. Great looking cars. :rollsmile:
Waseem 333i
Active member
The 6 cylinder f type is a hoot. Easy to drive and plenty theater with that exhaust. The V8 rwd is an animal. You need to be awake all the time for that. The AWD v8 is good and easy to drive but the weight takes away a lot of the feel which you get from the v6 one. If i had race car driver skills I would take the rwd v8 but because I don't I will be very very happy with the V6. If you take the convertible there will be no boot space.
If you want a practical car with theater AMG is the answer.
If you want a practical car with theater AMG is the answer.
Thanks for the suggestions and posts.
Finally after about 4 months ive decided to get an M5.
The M5 definitely suits my personality way more than the C63 seemed to. The C63's exhaust note is awesome but its just too loud and shouty for me. I dont know what it is but the C63 has a lazy character about it (not to say that its slow in anyway) where as to me the M5 feels like its always ready to go. Perhaps if i had the opportunity to drive a C63 more and maybe live with it i would change my opinion but as it stands thats how I feel. Another factor being that M5's are generally a lot cheaper than the mercs
As for the M3 / M4 option that changed very quickly after driving a V8 for the first time.
Tomorrow morning I'm going to pick up my new (old) M5 from SMG Umhlanga. Ill post some picks when its home.
Details about the car:
2014 F10 M5 Sedan
Colour: Alpine White III(300)
Trim: Leather Merino extended Black (LKSW)
20" M light alloy wheels Double-spoke style 343 M with mixed tyres
Extra options:
552 Adaptive LED headlights
431 Automatic anti-dazzle interior mirror
415 Rear screen roller blind, electric
323 Soft close automatic system for doors
6NR Apps
6AL BMW Live
322 Comfort Access
5AG Lane Change Warning
754 M Rear spoiler
Finally after about 4 months ive decided to get an M5.
The M5 definitely suits my personality way more than the C63 seemed to. The C63's exhaust note is awesome but its just too loud and shouty for me. I dont know what it is but the C63 has a lazy character about it (not to say that its slow in anyway) where as to me the M5 feels like its always ready to go. Perhaps if i had the opportunity to drive a C63 more and maybe live with it i would change my opinion but as it stands thats how I feel. Another factor being that M5's are generally a lot cheaper than the mercs
As for the M3 / M4 option that changed very quickly after driving a V8 for the first time.
Tomorrow morning I'm going to pick up my new (old) M5 from SMG Umhlanga. Ill post some picks when its home.
Details about the car:
2014 F10 M5 Sedan
Colour: Alpine White III(300)
Trim: Leather Merino extended Black (LKSW)
20" M light alloy wheels Double-spoke style 343 M with mixed tyres
Extra options:
552 Adaptive LED headlights
431 Automatic anti-dazzle interior mirror
415 Rear screen roller blind, electric
323 Soft close automatic system for doors
6NR Apps
6AL BMW Live
322 Comfort Access
5AG Lane Change Warning
754 M Rear spoiler
Kolbe
Member
stephen said:Thanks for the suggestions and posts.
Finally after about 4 months ive decided to get an M5.
The M5 definitely suits my personality way more than the C63 seemed to. The C63's exhaust note is awesome but its just too loud and shouty for me. I dont know what it is but the C63 has a lazy character about it (not to say that its slow in anyway) where as to me the M5 feels like its always ready to go. Perhaps if i had the opportunity to drive a C63 more and maybe live with it i would change my opinion but as it stands thats how I feel. Another factor being that M5's are generally a lot cheaper than the mercs
As for the M3 / M4 option that changed very quickly after driving a V8 for the first time.
Tomorrow morning I'm going to pick up my new (old) M5 from SMG Umhlanga. Ill post some picks when its home.
Details about the car:
2014 F10 M5 Sedan
Colour: Alpine White III(300)
Trim: Leather Merino extended Black (LKSW)
20" M light alloy wheels Double-spoke style 343 M with mixed tyres
Extra options:
552 Adaptive LED headlights
431 Automatic anti-dazzle interior mirror
415 Rear screen roller blind, electric
323 Soft close automatic system for doors
6NR Apps
6AL BMW Live
322 Comfort Access
5AG Lane Change Warning
754 M Rear spoiler
Congrats. You will not be sorry, these are absolutely awesome cars and they just do everything well. That V8 is awesome and unique! I have owned and driven just about everything from BMW (BMW employee for 28 years) and just love my F10 M5. Post some pics:=):.
Dirtydeedsman
Active member
M5 would have been my choice as well, Congrats
C63 unless its the M156 engine its a waste
C63 unless its the M156 engine its a waste
St Lunatic
///Member
F10 M5 all the way. I was in the same situation.
You wont get bored of the M5. when you do, do small mods then hold on tight :rollsmile:
You wont get bored of the M5. when you do, do small mods then hold on tight :rollsmile:
shiven-zn
Member
Brother try the new Alfa ...... I would seriously cosier it for the ff reasons. ..
1. This is the most important. ...I believe. ..NOT A HIJACKING WANTED LIST CAR...family and your safety 1st:chef:...other brand cars getting jacked Daily. .:chef:
2. Low insurance due to this.
3 decent, if not a very underrated car. Handling and performance department. A SLEEPER OF NOTE :tiptoe:
4 . Its different , makes you stand out of the regular choices around that prices range.
5.brand new car at that price and change left over as compared 2 used of other cars.
6. Definitely better on fuel then them all
7 . just as bad andgood on Resale as the bunch.
8. Pretty and sporty car..... I like the looks personally.
Things to consider. ..:crazylaugh:
Good luck bro. .:coolShake:
1. This is the most important. ...I believe. ..NOT A HIJACKING WANTED LIST CAR...family and your safety 1st:chef:...other brand cars getting jacked Daily. .:chef:
2. Low insurance due to this.
3 decent, if not a very underrated car. Handling and performance department. A SLEEPER OF NOTE :tiptoe:
4 . Its different , makes you stand out of the regular choices around that prices range.
5.brand new car at that price and change left over as compared 2 used of other cars.
6. Definitely better on fuel then them all
7 . just as bad andgood on Resale as the bunch.
8. Pretty and sporty car..... I like the looks personally.
Things to consider. ..:crazylaugh:
Good luck bro. .:coolShake:
