discussion Which should I pick? Low mileage vs better spec

DrussTW

Member
I’m in the market for my first ever beemer. Looking at getting a X3. I am presented with these 2 that fits my budget, both are 2018:

Option 1:
- mileage: 72000km
- xLine equipment
- Park assist plus (360 camera etc)
- Nav professional (bigger infotainment screen)
- Full digital instrument cluster
- adaptive LED with high beam assist
- fully electric operated tow bar
- spare wheel
- hifi sound system

Option 2:
- mileage: 57000km
- xLine equipment
- front and rear pdc
- nav business (smaller infotainment screen)
- analogue instrument cluster (not even the semi digital version)
- base sound system
- galvanised buttons
- panoramic roof

Option 2 is 20k cheaper.

My heart tells me option 1, but my brain tells me option 2!

Which would you choose and why?
 
Last edited:

rodga

Well-known member
I don't think 15k km makes a difference in the grand scheme of things. Take the one that's in better condition. If the same then the better spec wins.

Sent from my SM-S908E using Tapatalk
 

MR_Y

Well-known member
The factory fitted spare wheel holder (car option 1) impacts the luggage space in the boot. See the car in person and judge if that reduction in space will suit you.
12333-e72653d9ba76c2a762dc38eca56834e9.jpg12334-080a46f19e896004726abb08da509b8b.jpg

If you get option 2 and fit a spare wheel yourself, with a tie down net, it does not reduce the boot space as bad as the factory fitted spare wheel.

On the tech side, option 1 is much better.

Check the VIN history independently (either with a VIN check service or with Coisman on this forum) on both cars, noting that BMW Motorplan comments do not mean much if the car was repaired outside the BMW network.
 

Attachments

  • 12333-e72653d9ba76c2a762dc38eca56834e9 (1).jpg
    12333-e72653d9ba76c2a762dc38eca56834e9 (1).jpg
    58.1 KB · Views: 20

VinceM

Well-known member
Option 1.

You will live with the features daily (making your journeys a better experience than option 2), which are tangible vs. 15kms mileage difference which is intangible.
 

YozTruly

Well-known member
Hi DrussTW.

There are quite a few things that you must consider. Ultimately, it’s down to personal preference (obviously) but here it goes :-

What useful features does your current car have? Do not go back on “useful” features you currently have, it will suck and may give you buyers remorse. E.g. if you have reverse cameras and all-round PDC currently, don’t get a car without.

Panoramic Sunroofs: This is a personal preference thing and you never know whether you like them or not until you have one. I am indifferent about them. I loved it when I had it and don’t notice it now that I don’t have it. The most useful feature is the vent function (which is equally achieved by cracking a window, as the Americans would say). If you live in a sunny, hot place, the rest of the sunroof is unusable unless you keep the blind/net closed and that is something I never got comfortable with - feels like it will tear in the wind.
Panoramic sunroofs come in handy for night drives and on gloomy/overcast days - just beautiful. Did I say I’m indifferent about them somewhere? LOL!

NB: if you do significant gravel roads, they tend to squeak here and there but are fine once you are back on tar roads. PS: costs a pretty penny to clean and lubricate at the dealership when you take the car in for a service.

Electric tow bars: I struggle to see a situation where you need your tow bar retracted (I am open for an education here). After towing, the second most useful feature of a tow bar is the “anti-fender bender” - keep it extended and it helps against a slow rolling car in traffic with a texting driver. My opinion, it doesn’t need to be electrically operated nor does it need to be removable. Bonus: I think they look fantastic on the X3.

Infotainment Screens: If you are going to have a permanent tablet stuck to your dash, it might as well be the big one. The small ones have too much bezel for no good reason.

High beam assist: This is a game changer if you do significant night driving out in open roads (no street lights). It seems gimicky when you hear about it but damn does it change your life. It’s like automatic wipers, at first you think how lazy am I to need a car to tell me it’s raining? Then it rains and you are like wow! It even knows the intensity of the rain! These high beam assist things are useful. Admittedly, it’s not a feature you get to experience daily but damn. Okay, you get the picture.

72000 km vs 57000 km: It’s hard to not think in terms of mileage especially when one car has 50% more mileage than the other but this is really not the end of the world, especially if you plan to keep the car for a long time. After a few years of ownership you won’t think about mileage. It’s the everyday things that will keep you loving the car.

Which to buy: There is an unmistakable feeling you get when you sit inside a car, especially a pre-owned one. Get inside both of them and get a feel of the car, see if it tells you anything about the previous owner, tug and pull at a few things and feel if anything seems off and then see which one moves you - welcome to cliché corner - and then buy the 72000 km one. Jokes, aside, if at the end of the day you aren’t 100% sure about either, don’t buy and keep looking. The X3 is BMWs best seller ATM and that means there will be many coming up for sale in the second hand market on a regular basis.

TLDR: if I was forced between the two and all things were equal besides spec, mileage and price, I’m taking the 72000 km one - better spec = better overall ownership experience.
 
I tend to follow the more pragmatic route. Look at the average annual mileage that you intend to cover per year and then divide the 15k lower km. To me this is the value of the car in terms of less wear etc. The added extras are fine but not absolutely essential. On the other hand if the extras really appeal then check the history of the car in detail before buying.
 

MR_Y

Well-known member
Option 1 bud.

The loss is boot space with the factory fitted spare wheel is an acceptable opportunity cost for peace of mind in the event of an incident. Also negates the cost of having to purchase a spare wheel, jack and wheel spanner which is not cheap.
The spare wheel and jack cost I think is around R8k. But valid point you make 👍
 

modocrat

Well-known member
I came across this on Marketplace the other night.

I know the seller, we were in school together..

 

DrussTW

Member
Thanks guys. I expect to put on about 17k-20k km a year, hence I'm giving thought to the lower mileage one as the difference equates to approx "1 year's" worth of driving. So, my thoughts exactly @Preggie Naidoo
I tend to follow the more pragmatic route. Look at the average annual mileage that you intend to cover per year and then divide the 15k lower km. To me this is the value of the car in terms of less wear etc. The added extras are fine but not absolutely essential. On the other hand if the extras really appeal then check the history of the car in detail before buying.

I assume this is option 1:

Option 2
@MR_Y precisely :) how are you finding the povo spec, after 2 years?

I came across this on Marketplace the other night.

I know the seller, we were in school together..

@modocrat I reached out to this guy, but I get the feeling he's not that keen to sell haha. Just does not get back to me or keen to meet for a test drive. Other than that though, it's also quite a lot higher mileage in reality. it's not 77k per the ad, it's actually closer to 81k now. Otherwise this would been a strong contender
 

DrussTW

Member
On long term ownership... I'm looking at 5 years or 150,000km probably. When does the resale drop drastically?
I plan to go into full EV just waiting for the right time, so this is an "interim" solution
 

modocrat

Well-known member
Thanks guys. I expect to put on about 17k-20k km a year, hence I'm giving thought to the lower mileage one as the difference equates to approx "1 year's" worth of driving. So, my thoughts exactly @Preggie Naidoo



@MR_Y precisely :) how are you finding the povo spec, after 2 years?


@modocrat I reached out to this guy, but I get the feeling he's not that keen to sell haha. Just does not get back to me or keen to meet for a test drive. Other than that though, it's also quite a lot higher mileage in reality. it's not 77k per the ad, it's actually closer to 81k now. Otherwise this would been a strong contender
Most X3 owners can't let go easily 😅
 

AshG108

///Member
I just went through this in the last 2 months, if you going to worry about resale then try getting an MSport spec...however if not then the XLine is fine. I went with lower mileage on a 2018 model because many of the later models looked like dog's breakfasts compared to h the one I ended up getting.

So many people asked me why did I think of motorplan for longer and I went with a higher mileage, 2018 in impeccable condition than a 2021 which looks like the owner did cartwheels in it.
The car is super solid and the mileage is nothing to worry about because the car drives solid, the engines are solid also and maintenance is not that bad, but even if motorplan lapses...many ways to skin that cat.
I would say go with which one is best condition and you can see was afforded mechanical sympathy...knowing that the car will serve you well whe you have ownership of it.
 

MR_Y

Well-known member
These cars are mechanically solid.
Just perform oil changes every 10,000km.
My car has/had some cosmetic issues - but I assume this is due to it being an early production model made in SA.

The higher spec car seems like the better option, but just check the boot space and maybe consider a roof box if you need more space.

VIN check is a must to give peace of mind.
 

DrussTW

Member
I just went through this in the last 2 months, if you going to worry about resale then try getting an MSport spec...however if not then the XLine is fine. I went with lower mileage on a 2018 model because many of the later models looked like dog's breakfasts compared to h the one I ended up getting.

So many people asked me why did I think of motorplan for longer and I went with a higher mileage, 2018 in impeccable condition than a 2021 which looks like the owner did cartwheels in it.
The car is super solid and the mileage is nothing to worry about because the car drives solid, the engines are solid also and maintenance is not that bad, but even if motorplan lapses...many ways to skin that cat.
I would say go with which one is best condition and you can see was afforded mechanical sympathy...knowing that the car will serve you well whe you have ownership of it.
I haven't seen either myself as I don't live in jozi anymore and I'll be buying partly out of trust of my mate's judgement, but according to him the lower mileage one definitely feels newer and has fewer scratches on the black trims etc. his comment on the higher mileage one was that it was neat but could sense it's a 2018 model. one of the major giveaways is the partially scratched out start/stop button.

at this point in time, I'm leaning towards the higher mileage...
 
Top