Whisteling sound from engine when temp is hot

murphy69

New member
Hi guys,

I DESPERATELY need some help in determining what's causing a "whisteling" sound on my 2001 318i E46 (pre-facelift) BMW. At 197,000Km at present. After sending my car in for a major services, it started making this sound but only after you've been driving a while (temperature shows normal - no overheating). It sounds like worn out breaks, but it comes from infront of the engine. Not sure exactly where, but around the pullies, water filter and alternator area.

With the major service they replaced the spark plugs, air filter, oil filter, breather pipe, skimmed the breaks, brake pads and the normal things (oil etc.). Nothing out of the ordinary. They also replaced another filter of some sort appearantly under the engine/car, and I had the radiotor replaced because it was leaking and old. They also did a 49-point check on the car during the major service.

It's been back to a mechanic now three times, and they replaced the waterfilter and breather pipe with original BMW parts. I also had to replace the 2 tensioner pullies (small ones infront of the engine), but it turned out that they weren't the cause.

Te "whisteling" noise only starts after I'ved driven around a bit, and as soon as I accelerate the noise goes away. As soon as I let go of the petrol while driving or just idling, it's back again. The funny thing is that when you pull out the oil dipstick, the sound goes away immediately after a burst of air leaves the enigne through the dipstick tunnel. This means tat the engine is buiding up too much preassure, but it's not overheating at all or causing any reduction in power whatsoever.

Both mechanics are dub-struck (like me). They don't know what it could be, ut my argument is that the car wasn't making this noise when I took it in for the service, but now it is. I even got the first mechanic (from a nationwide chain of service centres) to go over everything AGAIN that they worked on and replaced, and they found everything in order.

Has anyone out there heard of something like this before, or could anyone give me some advice?

Thanks, Hein.[/size][/font]
 

murphy69

New member
Thanks for your replies, but it doesn't sound like that (oil separator) at all. It honestly sounds like when your brake pads are worn and you're braking, but it comes from infront of the engine (whisteling sound), and only when you're not excellerating. When you pull the dipstick out, the whisteling sound goes away, and air comes out of the engine immediately. There's no "wrong" sounds after that coming from the engine.

I'll try to record a video when it happens again.
 

Don

New member
Check your water level cause you could have a small hole in a waterpipe somewhere. That might also explain why it only happens when the engine is hot.
 

murphy69

New member
Thanks for the reply Don, but the waterlevel is perfect. I'll try to make a plan today to record a video, because it's driving me insane!
 

fhm1

New member
murphy69 said:
Hi guys,

I DESPERATELY need some help in determining what's causing a "whisteling" sound on my 2001 318i E46 (pre-facelift) BMW. At 197,000Km at present. After sending my car in for a major services, it started making this sound but only after you've been driving a while (temperature shows normal - no overheating). It sounds like worn out breaks, but it comes from infront of the engine. Not sure exactly where, but around the pullies, water filter and alternator area.

With the major service they replaced the spark plugs, air filter, oil filter, breather pipe, skimmed the breaks, brake pads and the normal things (oil etc.). Nothing out of the ordinary. They also replaced another filter of some sort appearantly under the engine/car, and I had the radiotor replaced because it was leaking and old. They also did a 49-point check on the car during the major service.

It's been back to a mechanic now three times, and they replaced the waterfilter and breather pipe with original BMW parts. I also had to replace the 2 tensioner pullies (small ones infront of the engine), but it turned out that they weren't the cause.

Te "whisteling" noise only starts after I'ved driven around a bit, and as soon as I accelerate the noise goes away. As soon as I let go of the petrol while driving or just idling, it's back again. The funny thing is that when you pull out the oil dipstick, the sound goes away immediately after a burst of air leaves the enigne through the dipstick tunnel. This means tat the engine is buiding up too much preassure, but it's not overheating at all or causing any reduction in power whatsoever.

Both mechanics are dub-struck (like me). They don't know what it could be, ut my argument is that the car wasn't making this noise when I took it in for the service, but now it is. I even got the first mechanic (from a nationwide chain of service centres) to go over everything AGAIN that they worked on and replaced, and they found everything in order.

Has anyone out there heard of something like this before, or could anyone give me some advice?

Thanks, Hein.[/size][/font]


Could be one your belt tensioners. Its worth a check..
 

bmw111

New member
from previous experience if you pull the dip stick and as you describe a lot of air comes out that normally means sump compression. but i can be wrong because there normally is not a noise that comes with it.

maybe have a compression test done to be safe.
 
Top