Sell or Keep?

Motalieb

New member
Howsit,

Need some advice, I have a E46 320d facelift 2004, currently on 280 000km. I am currently experiencing huge black clouds of smoke and fuel dropping quickly. Mech said something about injectors but still needs to check it up. the question is should I fix and sell? or should I just keep her and deal with the problems as it comes?:bin:
 

sash

///Member
Welcome, it is preferred to have an intro thread so that members can better relate to your situation.
 

Maljan

Active member
Hi, I have found myself in this situation too. I know and feel your pain. Our 325i has done a similar distance and I am gatvol with all the things that keep breaking. I had to charge the battery over the weekend when it went dead. The car is back on the road but I don't have a good feeling about that battery's ability to hold a charge.

It is a tough one. You will find that the car is not worth very much, especially if there is some mechanical malady. It is better to fix and then sell. Probably. But then one gets the feeling that the car now owes you money and it has to pay you back with a few more months/years of service. Unfortunately, an old E46 may just find another way to get into your wallet while serving out that sentence. Ask me. I have been there.

If you do sell you will not get something else that is better for the same money. In fact, you might get someone else's problem car. So you can stick with the devil you know.

On the other hand, this may just be the latest in a long list of repairs already done. In that case one feels that the time has come to cut your losses and move on. Just know that you will have to cough up to get what you are used to. An E46 is a nice car when everything works and a Golf or a Corolla will just not do. Anyway, there is no such thing as a cheap Corolla, it seems. If it is still running, a Corolla is worth serious money. Go figure.
 

KPM3_30

Moderator
Staff member
Maljan said:
Hi, I have found myself in this situation too. I know and feel your pain. Our 325i has done a similar distance and I am gatvol with all the things that keep breaking. I had to charge the battery over the weekend when it went dead. The car is back on the road but I don't have a good feeling about that battery's ability to hold a charge.

It is a tough one. You will find that the car is not worth very much, especially if there is some mechanical malady. It is better to fix and then sell. Probably. But then one gets the feeling that the car now owes you money and it has to pay you back with a few more months/years of service. Unfortunately, an old E46 may just find another way to get into your wallet while serving out that sentence. Ask me. I have been there.

If you do sell you will not get something else that is better for the same money. In fact, you might get someone else's problem car. So you can stick with the devil you know.

On the other hand, this may just be the latest in a long list of repairs already done. In that case one feels that the time has come to cut your losses and move on. Just know that you will have to cough up to get what you are used to. An E46 is a nice car when everything works and a Golf or a Corolla will just not do. Anyway, there is no such thing as a cheap Corolla, it seems. If it is still running, a Corolla is worth serious money. Go figure.

On the part about the battery not holding a charge, have a look at your alternator.. Had to do a repair on mine and change the battery.. E46's are getting on in years and everything will need some sort of attention, ask me :hammerhead:
 

Maljan

Active member
KPM_330 said:
On the part about the battery not holding a charge, have a look at your alternator.. Had to do a repair on mine and change the battery..

I have recently done the alternator - replaced the voltage regulator assembly. Unfortunately the battery went down and was recharged a few times while that one played itself out. The charging light would come on and go out. The last time it happened the light stayed on. Unfortunately, my wife thought she could make it to the office and kept going instead of turning back. She almost made it... :(

I have a hunch that the battery has now been deep cycled once too many, but I don't feel like spending anything on the car. Like the opening post, I am thinking real hard about selling it.
 
Top