Future BMW owner.

RJLerm

New member
Hi Guys...and Gals.

New to the forum and been browsing a bit before introducing myself.

Time has come to upgrade the wife's car after a few snags the past 6 months with her car. Worst was the last issue where it was standing for almost 8 weeks trying to get it sorted...just could not find parts. Past 6 months that car has cost us over R20000! And nothing weird was replaced or fixed. It was one coil pack, major service with front discs and pads and a Ford timing belt kit (which we had to wait for almost 5 weeks from Ford!). January the ECU packed up...Ford don't supply anymore and had to get it fixed at DS Auto Electrical or whatever the place is called. And it's not that it's a uncommon car...it's bloody 2004 Ford Focus for crying out loud. Needless to say she lost all faith in it and just wants it gone!

We can't afford finance and will need to buy cash. Looking around a few BMW's caught my eye. I will be hard pressed to part with the same money for a Korean or Jap car than for a BMW!? Then the BMW have safety features that the Korean and Jap cars don't have. I'm well aware of the 'German Way' of preventative maintenance, I work on German printing presses, and understand that it will probably cost even more for the BMW, but then again...you get what you pay for hey!?

Also, I know 2 people who owns e46 318's. Both 2001 models and manual. One have over 260000Km and other over 300000Km and both still going strong and in everyday use. Both claim that's it the best and most reliable cars that they have ever owned.

Considering what I've read on this forum and elsewhere I've decided that a e46 320i manual facelift can be a good option for the wife. She probably drives about 5000Km a year max! This includes a few trips to her folks in Oudtshoorn...we're in Cape Town. Are there any reason why the e46 320i manual will be a bad idea?

Your input will be greatly appreciated!

PS...I own a 2015 Ford Tourneo Grand Connect bus. Last service, 35000Km, the brakes were shot! Ford charged me R6000 for front and rear brake pads plus skiming the front discs...including labour.
 

Jeremy.d

Active member
Welcome.
My personal opinion is to go smaller for her, maybe 318i. I don't really think the power out of that 2.2l is worth the economy of a 6 cylinder engine.
 

Pho3niX90

///Member
I agree with Jeremy.d
The 320 is heavier on fuel than that of the 318, and not much more power. Also more expensive to maintain.
Rather go 318, 328 or 330
 

RJLerm

New member
I looked at the 318, but alot of forum members advise against it. Oil leaks and other problems comes to mind. I wouldn't mind a 328 or 330, but geez they're like hen's teeth. Actually surprised to see so many 318 and 320's for sale compared to the 6's.

Also a bit causios about the auto boxes...will rather prefer manual. Then again...dual mass flywheels and clutch kit is almost the prise of auto rebuild?

I'll even look at the e36...alot more straight 6 models to choose from.

I don't know...hopefully you guys can advise what's best.
 

TBP88

Well-known member
Why not consider an e90 320d? Not sure of your price range, but those are very common...
 

RJLerm

New member
Thanks all for the replies so far.

Not really a fan of diesel vehicles...and most e90's are out of my price range.
 

KPM3_30

Moderator
Staff member
Jeremy.d said:
Welcome.
My personal opinion is to go smaller for her, maybe 318i. I don't really think the power out of that 2.2l is worth the economy of a 6 cylinder engine.

Based solely on the reliability of the facelift 318i's, I would stay far away. Get your point on fuel economy but that 2.2 6 cylinder is smooth as silk and genuinely offers fair performance. Those engines are pretty damn solid as well!
 

SMN325

Member
Welcome

You could go for 318i or 320i, however make sure to consult the forums first (3 series) for some advice on what to look out for. Considering the age of the car you are looking for, the reliability is not based on the engine size/config but rather on how it has been looked after
 

RJLerm

New member
Thank you so far for all the advise...much appreciated!

I'll definitely consult the forum before buying. I'm extremely full of crap when looking at second hand vehicles. I tend to look at everything...even lying under the car and looking at the underside with a flashlight. I use to work at KE Panelbeaters years back, think I saw forum members mentioning them, so I can fairly easily spot if the body have been fixed.

Forum members will need to help out here with the mechanical side of things.

Looked at a e90 320 auto today. 150000km and the head have been replaced for some reason. Looked in the engine bay and the whole front of the engine are wet with oil...even oil on the stone tray under engine. Driving it was horrible...wondering all over road. Almost like if the front wheels are running at tow out. Car also don't react to small steering wheel inputs...turn the steering wheel and only after a while the car starts to change direction. Not to mention it's bloody lazy...flooring at around 2000rpm the auto dont gear down. It stayed in that gear...can't be normal? Never planned on buying it, but at least I scored a test drive...only my 2nd time driving a BMW.
 
Top