New car choices

2

200 octane

Member
Hi guys, I think my previous topic has changed somewhat and is now misleading. Apologies for the additional thread but I tried to change topic but can't seem to do it.

Anyway, a little history; my wife currently drives a 07 Rav4 2.2d4d vx model which is the top spec (keyless entry, leather, 4x4 6 speed, electric driver's seat)
I drive a Corsa bakkie but also have a 2013 Navara that I don't use and hope to sell soon.

I'm now considering to keep the Rav4 for me and replace the SO's car with one of the following. Minimal driving to be done since I have a fleet card for whichever vehicle I drive.

https://www.gumtree.co.za/a-cars-ba...000km-available-now/1005568755940910433768209

https://www.gumtree.co.za/a-cars-ba...000km-available-now/1005670431570910433768209

https://www.webuycars.co.za/buy-a-car/634280969??=facebook_selling_dynamicads_cpt

I will also consider Audi Q3 and Q5. Budget is around 200k. Car of choice will only be a runabout for SO to and from work and Rav4 will be the worker.
 
Twinz

Twinz

Forum - Support
Staff member
Try test drive the X1 & X3.
You will experience the bmw genetics in both and it may come down to your space requirements.

I own the X3 and X1 2011 20.d models and enjoy both. The X1 is lighter on fuel and both are Xdrive.

:thumbs:
 
2

200 octane

Member
Cool thanks. I drive the 2x X3's and they are awesome. It does feel a little heavy but power is not an issue at all.

The other factor that stands out for me is the multiple discussions about the getrag Vs zf gearbox.

Again with no BMW experience, any advice is appreciated. I'll be contacting BMW tomorrow with VIN checks
 
2

200 octane

Member
Hi guys. So I went to test drive all of the cars above. I must admit that I prefer the X3 with the smoother gear changes and slightly more space. The X1 23d is definitely faster but you feel all of the gearshifts. The spec of the X1 above is similar to that of the white X3. It had quite a few scratches on the touchscreen display which is noticeable when not illuminated.

Kimberley's got talent:praise:
https://www.gumtree.co.za/a-cars-bakkies/kimberley/bmw-x3-30d/1005410462000911022462609

Kimberley's got talent:praise:
https://www.gumtree.co.za/a-cars-bakkies/kimberley/bmw-x3-30d/1005410462000911022462609
 
V

vjx

Member
20d with 2TB gearbox usually can fit BMW PPK in.
With PPK, 20d is close to 23d/25d performance.
 
Z

zaheer

Active member
I enquired about this car when I was hunting for a 30d X3. This one was involved in an accident and thereafter facelifted.

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
 
MR_Y

MR_Y

Well-known member
Hi,

If the SO drives short distances or much in traffic, then a turbo diesel may not be the best option. The DPF may get clogged and cause expensive problems down the line.

https://www.theaa.com/driving-advice/fuels-environment/diesel-particulate-filters

A good petrol may be the better choice, unless the car will be given sufficient long distance running.

Also, why not consider one of the Japanese brands, given that 2 of your vehicles are already Japs? X-trail or CX5 2.0 petrols are quite good.
 
2

200 octane

Member
Thanks for that info. I'll open its legs from time to time and do a nice trip although for the most part, the car will do 40km per day and rest most weekends.

As far as Japanese brands go, the SO likes the CX3 but it's out of the budget, the CX5 is too big. My wife is 1.45m tall/short

Thanks for that info. I'll open its legs from time to time and do a nice trip although for the most part, the car will do 40km per day and rest most weekends.

As far as Japanese brands go, the SO likes the CX3 but it's out of the budget, the CX5 is too big. My wife is 1.45m tall/short

Not sure why the above post is duplicated and also missing some info. Anyway, I also found the following X3

2011 BMW X3 20d Msport
143k mileage
Dealer maintenance upto 100k after which RMI took over
Car is based in Durban.
Full Msport spec I believe with 18 inch wheels, sunroof, PDC, voice control and whatever else that means.

Basically, I want one with black leather, sunroof, PDC, auto zf. Finishes are not of too much importance. I have a 3 year old who will most likely think of innovative ways to damage whatever we get:dunnoanymore:
Price is 200k however they are going to see what price they can offer me. The car has been there for just over a month.

I'll probably create a thread asking for assistance to go and view on my behalf soon.
 
Z

zaheer

Active member
200 octane said:
Thanks for that info. I'll open its legs from time to time and do a nice trip although for the most part, the car will do 40km per day and rest most weekends.

As far as Japanese brands go, the SO likes the CX3 but it's out of the budget, the CX5 is too big. My wife is 1.45m tall/short

Thanks for that info. I'll open its legs from time to time and do a nice trip although for the most part, the car will do 40km per day and rest most weekends.

As far as Japanese brands go, the SO likes the CX3 but it's out of the budget, the CX5 is too big. My wife is 1.45m tall/short

Not sure why the above post is duplicated and also missing some info. Anyway, I also found the following X3

2011 BMW X3 20d Msport
143k mileage
Dealer maintenance upto 100k after which RMI took over
Car is based in Durban.
Full Msport spec I believe with 18 inch wheels, sunroof, PDC, voice control and whatever else that means.

Basically, I want one with black leather, sunroof, PDC, auto zf. Finishes are not of too much importance. I have a 3 year old who will most likely think of innovative ways to damage whatever we get:dunnoanymore:
Price is 200k however they are going to see what price they can offer me. The car has been there for just over a month.

I'll probably create a thread asking for assistance to go and view on my behalf soon.
Click to expand...
Is the based Durban one at Autovision and white in colour by chance?

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
 
Z

zaheer

Active member
200 octane said:
Yes. Are we considering the same car?
Click to expand...
It was on my list but after hearing it has comments of an accident I passed.
Might be a good purchase if repaired well though and I was told it has a new set of tyres on.

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

DeadbeatFM
discussion Advice needed - 2024 X3 30d vs 2025 X3 30e
Replies
9
Views
2K
AshG108
AshG108
N
Porsche 911
2 3
Replies
58
Views
4K
Rocky_cpt
Rocky_cpt
Liam H
technical N55 Soot on rear bumper. Running Rich Or Normal?
Replies
2
Views
470
Liam H
Liam H
JosephGrobler
Leather seat care for my F30 BMW 330D
Replies
14
Views
1K
MLorgat
MLorgat
S
E82 120d - Ten Years of Ownership Advice Please
2
Replies
20
Views
2K
Shivaal Tiluk
S
Top